The Worst Cities for the Average Family in the US: Cost Considerations and Crime

When considering the best places for an average family to live in the US, two key factors come to mind: cost and safety. If we focus on affordability, two metropolitan areas stand out as unaffordable for the average household. San Francisco and Manhattan, New York City, are among the most expensive places to live.

Cost Considerations

According to recent data, the median annual household income in the U.S. is approximately $52,000. After taxes, this drops to around $40,000 in California and $39,000 in New York City. For reference, the average rent for a one-bedroom apartment in San Francisco is $3,500 per month, equating to an annual rent of $42,000. Similarly, the average rent in Manhattan is about $3,200 per month, totaling $38,400 annually. Both these amounts are approximately equal to the median post-tax income for an average household, making these cities almost entirely unaffordable.

Suburban Living and Urban Crime

While the cities mentioned above are unaffordable for the average family, the question remains: where are the worst places to live? Among urban settings, neighborhoods in Detroit and New Orleans stand out as particularly unfavorable due to high crime rates. New Orleans, a city known for its rich culture and history, unfortunately, has a homicide rate that surpasses that of Somalia, a country often associated with extreme violence. Although the actual risk is lower, at around 58 in 100,000, the perception of danger can be detrimental to raising a family.

Suburban Alternatives and Cost Comparison

For the vast majority of average Americans, living in the suburbs is more realistic. Here, life is less crowded, more affordable, and generally safer. According to data from urban planning studies, the average American commutes between 10 to 30 miles to work, typically in a car or bus, from the suburbs. When compared to well-known cities like San Diego, Seattle, and Portland, which are beloved for their affordability and lifestyle, average families spend significantly more in rent in major US cities. In some parts of Canada, Australia, and Europe, the cost of living can be much lower, especially in urban centers.

Conclusion

In conclusion, for the average family, the worst cities to consider living in are those that are extremely expensive and unsafe, such as certain neighborhoods in Detroit and New Orleans. These cities pose significant challenges for families, both in terms of cost and safety. However, for the vast majority of Americans, the suburbs offer a more balanced and affordable alternative that is well-suited for raising a family.