Rural Environments: Cultivating Toughness or Self-Reliance?

Does growing up in a rural environment produce tougher individuals? Not necessarily 'tougher,' but more self-reliant. This article explores the unique characteristics and advantages of rural living and outdoor activities, particularly in areas like Brewster County, Texas.

Self-Reliance in Rural Communities

Brewster County, Texas, is an excellent example of a rural environment. It is roughly the same size as the state of Connecticut but has only one town with a population of around 10,000 people. Growing up in Brewster County, an individual's expectations of what society or the government will provide are considerably lower compared to someone raised in cities like Brooklyn or Queens, New York. In rural areas such as Brewster County, people quickly learn to solve their own problems, making them more self-reliant.

Benefits of Living Outdoors

Outdoor living does not only instill toughness but can also contribute to personal development and resilience. Tasks like herding cattle, milking cows, shearing sheep, harvesting maize, and hauling in shrimp cannot be done indoors, emphasizing the importance of physical and mental fortitude. However, one must also consider indoor activities, such as tweeting incessantly at 6 in the morning or getting one's hair done. These examples reflect the contrast between rural and urban lifestyles and highlight how outdoor programs like Outward Bound can help individuals develop hardiness. Exploring nature, living outdoors, and enduring physically and mentally demanding tasks can significantly impact a person's character and resilience.

The Role of Outdoor Activities in Military Recruitment

The debate extends beyond individual development into fields such as military recruitment. Historical and anecdotal evidence from the American Civil War suggests that while the South initially had more experienced field commanders, they were often fighting with their backs against the wall. This environment required them to be particularly resourceful and resilient, leading to a higher representation of individuals from rural backgrounds in special forces and challenging military roles.

Another example comes from Norway, where people from rural backgrounds have historically been well-represented in special forces and challenging duties within conventional forces, such as recon and snipers. Many of these individuals have prior experience in hunting, allowing them to hit targets accurately and move quietly. Outdoor activities in general, such as hunting and outdoor sports, equip rural individuals with essential skills that prepare them for challenging military or law enforcement roles.

Urban Examples and Resilience

While rural areas cultivate a sense of self-reliance and toughness, it is important to note that not all individuals from urban environments are unprepared when faced with challenges. A naval special forces veteran, despite having grown up in the city, still demonstrated exceptional resilience and dedication. This example shows that toughness and self-reliance can also develop in urban environments through personal experiences and specific challenges.

Ultimately, the impact of a rural environment on the development of an individual's resilience and toughness is significant but multifaceted. Growing up in a rural area provides unique opportunities to develop self-reliance and resilience through exposure to outdoor activities and physical demands. However, individuals from urban backgrounds can also become resilient and tough through a variety of personal experiences and challenges.

To further explore this topic, read more about the benefits of outdoor living. Whether you're in a rural or urban environment, embracing outdoor activities and facing challenges head-on can greatly enhance your personal growth and development.