Macallan 18 Year Old vs. Macallan 12 and 15 Year Old: Which Is Best?

When it comes to choosing between Macallan 18 year old, Macallan 12 year old, and Macallan 15 year old whiskies, opinions can vary widely. While one person might prefer the 18 year old for its complexity and richness, another might find the 12 year old more approachable. Let's delve deeper into what makes these whiskies special and help you understand why the preference can differ so much.

Understanding the Age and Quality

Generally, older whisky is considered to be of higher quality, not because it is simply left longer, but because it undergoes careful monitoring and selection. The distillery carefully samples and judges each spirit, deciding when it is most beneficial to leave the whisky in the barrel for longer and in what type of cask. While this is a general rule, your individual taste will still influence your preference.

There are times when a spirit can spend too much time in a barrel, leading to a loss of flavor. However, under the watchful eye of an active distillery, this does not typically happen. For instance, during a tasting session, I had the privilege of sampling a pure pot still Irish whisky distilled in 1953, which had been in a cask for at least 30 years. By the time it was bottled, it might have been over 40 years old. This whisky, from Old Comber, a silent or closed distillery, was so old that it resembled "licking a barrel stave – the outside." The sherry cask imparted no discernible flavor, indicating that the whisky's characteristics were mainly derived from the cask.

Why Macallan 18 Year Old Could Be Considered Superior

Macallan 18 year old whiskey is likely to be considered superior because it has aged longer. During its lifetime, the whisky is often re-casked, allowing it to absorb more flavors from different types of barrels. This process adds complexity and character, making it a more distinguished choice for those who appreciate a well-rounded, full-bodied whisky. The aging process ensures that the whisky develops a richer, more nuanced taste over time.

Go with Your Preferences

The real question is, which whisky do you enjoy drinking? Whether you aim to gain a reputation as a whisky connoisseur or simply want to savor a delightful glass, the most important factor is personal preference. If you find that the 12 year old Macallan is more to your liking, stick with it. Similarly, if the 15 or 18 year old offers a taste you enjoy, go for it.

It's crucial to remember that Macallan has garnered a reputation that some might argue is exaggerated. While it is a respected brand, the quality of a Macallan whisky depends on the specific batch and the distillery's quality control. It's worth trying different ages to find the one you genuinely enjoy, rather than following the hype.

Conclusion: The choice between Macallan 18, 15, and 12 year old whiskies ultimately comes down to personal taste. While age plays a significant role in the overall quality and character of a whisky, your enjoyment of the drink is what truly matters. So, why not try them all and see which one resonates with you the most?