Understanding Luffy's Grandfather (Garp): More Than Just a Source of Conflict

Many fans of the One Piece series often assume a straightforward hatred between Luffy and his grandfather, Admiral Garp. However, S Eugene Second reveals a more nuanced relationship between the two, where Luffy's journey and choices are shaped by multiple influences and motivations.

Admiral Garp's Dreams for Luffy

Admiral Garp, a proud and ambitious individual, dreams about Luffy becoming a Navy Admiral in the future. His vision for Luffy is not only focused on achieving personal glory within the Sea Guard but also aims to instill a sense of discipline and responsibility.
'I want to see my grandson become one of the greatest fighters. In the Navy. He must become a grand admiral someday.' - Garp, referring to his dream of Luffy joining the Navy.

Becoming Inspired by Shanks

Despite Garp's aspirations, Luffy's path to becoming a pirate is heavily influenced by the Yonko, Akagami no Shanks. Shanks, known for his pirate lifestyle and free spirit, becomes a symbol of rebellion and adventure for Luffy. As Shanks leaves Luffy with a promise, a literal as well as a figurative one, Luffy's journey begins to diverge from Garp's expectations.
'Luffy, remember, the sea doesn't belong to the Navy... It belongs to the pirates.' - Shanks, giving his last words to Luffy and setting his future path.
Shanks encourages Luffy to find his own way, and this inspires Luffy to aim for a grander goal: becoming the Pirate King.

Clashes Between Luffy and His Grandfather

The contrast between Garp's desire for Luffy to become a Navy Admiral and Luffy's aspiration to be a pirate leads to frequent clashes. These clashes are not merely a conflict of personalities but represent a broader theme of multiple generational values and personal ambitions colliding. A common narrative understood by fans often frames these clashes in a negative light, portraying Garp as a villain for hindering Luffy's dream. However, this perspective doesn't capture the full complexity of their relationship.

Respect and Promise: The Deep Layer of Their Connection

It's important to recognize that Luffy's grandfather holds a deep respect and admiration for Luffy's determination and ambition. Garp's actions, while seemingly obstructive, are more about ensuring that Luffy becomes a strong leader. Garp believes that Luffy needs to be properly trained and disciplined to face the challenges that come with being a pirate, much like he faced in his younger days as a fighter. This perspective can be seen when Luffy finally becomes a great pirate, Garp still sees him as his grandson and a worthy successor.

Why Garp Doesn't HATE Shanks

Perhaps the fascination and envy towards Shanks play a role in Garp's resentment, but it's not exactly hate. Garp's hatred for Shanks is more about the loss of control over Luffy's fate. Shanks symbolizes the freedom and rebellion that Garp trained Luffy to suppress. It's envious and perhaps a tinge of regret but not outright hate. Shanks is the catalyst that shaped Luffy's path, indirectly causing the clash with Garp. The irony is that Garp's intense training and discipline never managed to shape Luffy's desires as Shanks did.

Conclusion: Luffy’s Grandfather - A Supportive Adversary

In the grand narrative of the One Piece series, the relationship between Luffy and his grandfather Garp is complex and multifaceted. It's more about underlying tensions and respect for each other's paths rather than outright hatred. Understanding these dynamics enriches our appreciation of the story and the characters involved.

References

1. (Article) Admiral Garp does not hope if he knows of his dream-for-Luffy
2. (One Piece Fandom) Admiral Garp page