Critical Analysis of 'Planet of the Apes' (1968) - Examining Its Flaws

Pacing Issues

The film has moments where the pacing can feel uneven. Some sequences, especially in the first half, may drag on while others feel rushed. This inconsistency can detract from the overall viewing experience. Viewers may find themselves questioning the flow of the narrative, which could lead to a less engaging story.

Character Development

While the film has strong themes and social commentary, some characters, particularly the human protagonists, lack depth and development. This can make it difficult for viewers to fully connect with their struggles. Without well-developed characters, the audience may find it harder to empathize with their situations and the challenges they face.

Plot Holes

The film contains several plot holes and inconsistencies, particularly regarding the timeline of events and the evolution of the apes. For example, the mechanics of how humans became subservient and apes became dominant are not fully explained. These gaps in the storyline can leave viewers wondering about the credibility and logic behind the plot developments.

Special Effects Limitations

While the special effects and makeup in the film were groundbreaking for its time, they may appear dated to modern audiences. The ape costumes and makeup, while innovative, can sometimes break immersion. Viewers may find themselves distracted by the visual elements rather than fully engaged with the story and characters.

Abiguous Ending

The film's ending is iconic but can also be seen as ambiguous or confusing. The revelation about the Statue of Liberty may leave some viewers with more questions than answers about the world within the film. This ambiguity can add to the intrigue but may also be frustrating for those seeking clear resolutions.

Stereotypical Portrayal of Authority

The portrayal of the ape society can sometimes veer into caricature, with authority figures depicted in a way that might reinforce stereotypes rather than offering nuanced commentary. This can overshadow the film's intended social commentary and reduce its impact on the audience.

Personal Reflection on the Ending

The problem I saw when I first saw it in the theaters at age 12 was the ending. Spoiler alert!! In the iconic scene where the character dismounts to speak to the apes, one might wonder why he had seen the Statue of Liberty well before his arrival. There were even a few scenes where the humans and the back of the statue were visible. I kept wondering why he waited so long to address them. It seemed he must have seen it at least an hour in real time before his ending speech. Still, it was a dramatic moment that lives in the minds of everyone who saw the movie.

In a similar vein, the fact that the apes speak, read, and write in English raises questions about their exact location. If they are speaking English, it suggests that they are on Earth. However, the lack of diversity in the human characters, with all being white, prompts further speculation about the world they inhabit. The absence of racial diversity in the humans can be seen as a missed opportunity to address issues of diversity and representation.

In conclusion, while 'Planet of the Apes' (1968) is a groundbreaking film with powerful social commentary, it is not without its flaws. From pacing issues to plot inconsistencies and ambiguous endings, the film faces several challenges. However, its enduring legacy and impact on subsequent films and culture cannot be denied.